Tired of being critical?


September 17, 2024 - Read Online

Do you ever find yourself in a mood where people make you angry quicker than normal? When the thoughts in your head are more critical of others than usual? When you have very little patience for the inconveniences of normal, everyday life?

This past month I found myself being critical of my spouse and kids. I was grumbling (mainly internally) about dishes and messy kids rooms. Little critical words would slip out as I went about my day. And I am sure my face was not welcoming.

Then I had a moment of self reflection. I kicked myself. I asked "What is going on here? Why am I acting like this?"

As I reflected, I found a note I had written down after reading some of Jesse Coomer's book "The Language of Breath":

When a human is critical, jealous, or judgmental it is a sign that they are in a "fight-or-flight" state. They are trying to identify threats. So, when I am critical, jealous, or judgmental of others, it means I am feeling threatened.

Behind my feelings of criticism there is a sense of my feeling threatened. This realization has been revolutionary for me.

Back to my example. When I was critical of the messy house, I felt threatened without knowing it. I knew that a messy house wasn't a real danger to me, but for some reason my subconscious felt like it was. It could be that I was afraid of what guests would think, or that I would lose something I care about.

So - If you are like me and you find yourself feeling critical or judgmental of others, this is something to try.

The first step: we must admit that we would not feel critical or judgmental if we did not also feel threatened.

Once we admit this, the next step is to lead ourselves out of this threatened state. Then our criticism should stop.

The problem is, this does not feel natural to us. Many of us grew up learning that when we are being critical, jealous or judgmental, we are being bad. We simply need to stop it. We try to fix it by telling ourselves we are being bad.

We say things like "be positive!" or "be grateful!" or "be kind!"

And we kick and criticize ourselves for being critical of others. Where does this lead us?

To feeling more threatened.

Being critical of ourselves doesn't take us out of the "threatened" state, it does the opposite. Which leads us to be more critical and judgmental and impatient.

It's a terrible cycle. Our system still feels threatened. And so our system keeps fighting to get safe.

This may look like:

  • Explosions of unwanted emotions that we can't explain.
  • Acting out with food, drink, drug or screen to numb the feelings.
  • Chronic medical maladies.

This is all because we are not solving the core problem: feeling threatened.

We need to address this!

How? One way that helps: choosing to be curious and playful. Being curious is the opposite of the tunnel-vision caused by "fight-or-flight"

But - this will not come natural. As we have said before - you have to "practice" something you want to become, which looks a lot like "pretending" at first.

One way:

Be curious about that person you are feeling critical of. Take them to lunch and ask them questions about the things they care about. Get to know them.

Or, it could be too much to address the people you are critical of. If so, an easier place to start is this: take time to be curious about the world around you! Read a book on a topic that interests you. Ask someone you respect a question about something you wonder about. Set a timer for 20 minutes and sit and look at the clouds in the sky and let your mind wonder: how long is a cloud in the sky for? What does that cloud look like? What did humans 4,000 years ago think clouds were?

If you would like - you can even try and be curious about why you are feeling threatened (this is what I tend to do). Once you see the thing for what it actually is, you will likely see how you can take care of yourself in a healthy way.

When problems arise and we let our "threatened" state run us, we act like wild animals. We do whatever we can to survive.

But - when threats arise and we lead ourselves to be curious - amazing things can happen. We innovate, find breakthroughs, and make the world a better place.

So, if you find yourself being critical, judgmental or impatient, take heart! Take the time to lead yourself and practice curiosity. You will likely find clarity and peace and something better.

If we were logical, the future would be bleak indeed. But we are more than logical. We are human beings, and we have faith, and we have hope, and we can work.
- Jacques Cousteau

I hope this helps.

-Dave

If you know anyone who you think would value these emails, please forward this along!
If this email was forwarded to you, you can subscribe here.

On Becoming Good

Join me if you are looking to become more of the person you know you ought to be. These free, weekly meditations are inspired by a wide range of sources, including insightful books, philosophy, and encounters with intriguing individuals. I hope you find them useful as we explore the art of leading ourselves well.

Read more from On Becoming Good
A close up of a white owl with yellow eyes

September 10, 2024 - Read Online It is possible that we have more options of what to do with our time today than at any other time in human history. In many ways, this is a blessing, but it also makes life complicated. It means we have to make choices all day long, and this can be exhausting. More than that, the fact is, our choices effect the world around us. They effect the people around us. Often in ways we cannot see. It is hard to know the right thing to do. So, how do we figure it out?...

shallow focus photography of gray cable

August 27, 2024 - Read Online It took me a lot of work and self-examination to realize I was blaming other people for my lack of self-mastery. It is so easy to miss. I remember back in 2017, we had a brand new baby at home and I was planning to go on a run on a beautiful Saturday morning. My wife had been up most of the night with our one-week-old and felt wholly exhausted. When I said to her "I am going on a run," I could see immediately, in her eyes, that she did not want me to go. And I...

black puppy looking at cupcakes

August 20, 2024 - Read Online The reason most of us develop self-discipline is to achieve some sort of goal in our lives. To have success in one area or another. Examples: People diet and exercise because they have the goal of preventing heart disease. People study and practice in their work because they have the goal of advancing in their career. People go to therapy because they have a goal to enjoy life and they don't want to lose their relationships. I could keep going. We all have areas...